When a corpus of a genre is established two things tend to happen:
1. A list of films is compiled that respond to a simple tautological definition of genre (ie. Western = film that takes place in the west, cowboys, etc)
2. Critics, theoreticians that stick to a cannon that has little do with the tautological – Same films tend to be mentioned over and over – (kind of fanatic approach, leaning towards a classic cannon of films)
Contradiction lies at the heart of which movies belong where – opposed to the simplicity of their definitions.
The uncertainty is also associated with the relative “contradicting” status of theory and history genre studies.
Continue reading A semantic/syntactic approach to film genre